10 Reasons Why Gentle Parenting is Not Great for Indian Kids

Explore why gentle parenting might not suit Indian kids. Understand cultural nuances, academic pressures, and more in balancing modern and traditional methods.

8. Jun 2024
10 Reasons Why Gentle Parenting is Not Great for Indian Kids

Gentle parenting, a method that emphasizes empathy, respect, and understanding, has gained popularity worldwide. It advocates for positive reinforcement and avoids punitive measures. However, while the approach may have its merits, it might not be the best fit for every cultural context, including that of Indian families. Here are ten reasons why gentle parenting might not be ideal for Indian kids, considering cultural nuances, societal expectations, and practical challenges.

1. Cultural Expectations and Discipline

Indian culture places a strong emphasis on respect for elders and authority figures. Traditional parenting often involves a structured approach to discipline, which is seen as essential for instilling respect and obedience. Gentle parenting’s lenient stance might conflict with these deeply ingrained cultural norms, potentially leading to misunderstandings and behavioral issues.

Tip: Balancing gentle parenting techniques with traditional disciplinary methods can help align with cultural expectations while promoting positive behavior.

2. Extended Family Dynamics

In India, extended families play a crucial role in child-rearing. Grandparents, aunts, and uncles often contribute to a child's upbringing and may have differing views on discipline. Gentle parenting, which focuses on negotiation and empathy, may clash with the more authoritative style preferred by older generations, leading to family conflicts.

Tip: Open communication with extended family members about parenting choices can help create a supportive environment while respecting their perspectives.

Also Read - Bad Therapy: Why the Kids Aren't Growing Up

3. Academic Pressure

Indian society places significant emphasis on academic success. The competitive nature of the education system often necessitates a disciplined approach to studies. Gentle parenting’s flexible and child-led methods might not provide the structure and rigor required to meet these academic demands, potentially affecting a child’s performance.

Tip: Incorporate structured study schedules within a gentle parenting framework to ensure children meet academic expectations without excessive pressure.

4. Social Comparisons

Indian parents frequently compare their children’s achievements with those of their peers. Gentle parenting’s focus on individual growth rather than competition might not align with societal norms that value comparative success. This discrepancy can create tension and feelings of inadequacy among children and parents alike.

Tip: Encourage children to focus on personal growth and celebrate individual achievements, while gently guiding them to understand and navigate social comparisons.

5. Authority and Boundaries

Establishing clear boundaries is crucial for children’s development. In Indian culture, parents are often seen as authoritative figures who set firm limits. Gentle parenting’s collaborative approach might blur these boundaries, leading to confusion about authority and discipline.

Tip: Maintain clear boundaries and consistent rules while using gentle parenting techniques to foster respect and understanding.

Also Read - Is Your Baby Sleeping in An AC Room? 5 Things to Keep in Mind

6. Behavioral Expectations in Public

Indian society has specific expectations regarding children’s behavior in public. Gentle parenting, which allows for more freedom and self-expression, might not always conform to these expectations. This can result in social judgment and criticism from others, adding stress to both parents and children.

Tip: Prepare children for public settings by discussing acceptable behavior beforehand, balancing gentle guidance with societal expectations.

7. Economic Constraints

In many Indian households, economic constraints necessitate a more pragmatic approach to parenting. Gentle parenting often requires time, patience, and resources, which may not be feasible for families struggling to meet basic needs. The practical challenges of implementing this approach can outweigh its benefits in such contexts.

Tip: Adapt gentle parenting principles to fit within practical constraints, focusing on empathy and respect without extensive resource requirements.

8. Safety Concerns

Indian cities can pose various safety challenges, from busy traffic to crowded public spaces. Gentle parenting’s emphasis on autonomy and exploration might not be safe or practical in these environments, necessitating a more protective and vigilant approach.

Tip: Ensure children’s safety by setting clear boundaries and supervising them closely, while encouraging safe exploration within those limits.

Also Read - 10 Common Habits in Children Who Score High Marks

9. Community Influence

Community plays a vital role in child-rearing in India. Parents often rely on community norms and practices to guide their parenting decisions. Gentle parenting, which might be seen as unconventional, can lead to isolation or criticism from the community, making it harder for parents to maintain this approach consistently.

Tip: Build a supportive network of like-minded parents and educate the community about the benefits of gentle parenting to gain broader acceptance.

10. Balancing Modernity and Tradition

Indian parents often struggle to balance modern parenting philosophies with traditional values. Gentle parenting, with its progressive approach, might be seen as too modern or Western, causing friction with traditional beliefs and practices.

Tip: Integrate gentle parenting principles with traditional values, creating a hybrid approach that respects cultural heritage while embracing modern parenting methods.

Also Read - Why Labrador is the Best Dog to Play with Your Kids?


While gentle parenting offers many positive attributes, it is essential to consider the cultural, social, and practical contexts within which it is applied. For Indian families, striking a balance between gentle parenting techniques and traditional practices can help create a nurturing and respectful environment that meets both the needs of the child and the expectations of the community. By adapting and integrating different parenting styles, parents can provide the best of both worlds for their children.

Note - We can not guarantee that the information on this page is 100% correct. Some article is created with help of AI.


Downloading any Book PDF is a legal offense. And our website does not endorse these sites in any way. Because it involves the hard work of many people, therefore if you want to read book then you should buy book from Amazon or you can buy from your nearest store.


No comments has been added on this post

Add new comment

You must be logged in to add new comment. Log in
Rishabh Sinha
Check Information about technical products, Books, latest launched products and more.
Information, Tech News
Gaming Blog
Game Reviews, Information and More.
Learn Anything
Factory Reset
How to Hard or Factory Reset?
Books and Novels
Latest Books and Novels
Osclass Solution
Find Best answer here for your Osclass website.
Check full Information about Electronic Items. Latest Mobile launch Date. Latest Laptop Processor, Laptop Driver, Fridge, Top Brand Television.
Pets Blog
Check Details About All Pets like Dog, Cat, Fish, Rabbits and More. Pet Care Solution, Pet life Spam Information
Lately commented
Excellent post. I am facing a few of these issues as well..
Non-Health Reasons Your Cat Ha...